Blog Search

Showing posts with label Transgressive. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Transgressive. Show all posts

Irish Referendum Reforms Fall Flat

Despite being supported by all major political parties, proposals to amend Ireland’s 1937 constitution to revise language defining the role of women and the nature of the family have been comprehensively rejected by Irish voters in a double referendum held on International Women’s Day.



“Voters in Ireland rejected two proposed changes to the country’s Constitution that would have removed language about women’s duties being in the home and broadened the definition of family beyond marriage, dealing a blow to the government that analysts said suggested the weakness of their campaign to pass the proposals.


After a series of referendums in recent years had reshaped Ireland’s Constitution in ways that reflect the country’s more secular and liberal modern identity, the result came as a surprise to some, including the government. But analysts said that rather than signaling a step back from those values, the results reflected a confusing, disjointed campaign that had left many voters reluctant to vote yes.


Each proposal was defeated by a wide margin, according to the results, which were announced on Saturday, an unexpected defeat for equality campaigners and for the coalition government of Leo Varadkar, the taoiseach, or prime minister.


Despite the fact that all of the country’s major political parties supported both proposals, some critics said the proposed clauses did not go far enough, while others faulted phrasing that they said was too broad.


Irish citizens went to the polls on Friday, International Women’s Day, to vote in two referendums to amend the country’s 87-year-old Constitution, which was drafted when the Roman Catholic Church’s influence on many aspects of life in Ireland was immense.


Supporters viewed the proposed amendments as vital to ensuring that the Constitution reflected the country’s more secular and liberal modern identity. But many voted ‘no’ to both referendum questions.


Analysts and politicians said the results were more complex than a simple rejection of the proposed changes. A lower-than-expected voter turnout and confusing messaging by the ‘Yes’ campaign may have contributed to the proposals’ failures, they said.


Still, 44 percent of the population turned out for the vote, 67.7 percent of voters refused the changes on the family question, and 73.93 percent on the care question, according to the official results.


Laura Cahillane, an associate professor at the University of Limerick’s law school, who has written about the confusion around the referendums, said that people had concerns about wording from the start.


‘When people are confused, they are a lot more likely to vote no and reject change’, Ms. Cahillane said in an interview on RTÉ, the public broadcast network, on Saturday night.


The government must now look into what went wrong, she added, pointing to the long process by a Citizens’ Assembly that led to recommendations for the proposals, which were then evaluated by a legislative committee set up specifically for the purpose. But some recommendations had been ignored, and the government had introduced its own wording.


Opposition parties and others had warned that the language was confusing, according to Ms. Cahillane, and the government and the political parties did little campaigning to drum up support for the referendums.


‘There seemed to be very little interest in the government in listening to the concerns of people on the wording’, she said, ‘And maybe a certain amount of arrogance in that they believed that people might get carried away on a wave of feminism on International Women’s Day and simply pass these two referendums’.


The first referendum question voters were asked to consider was whether to amend the Constitution’s Article 41, to provide for a wider concept of family. The suggested language would have recognized a family, ‘whether founded on marriage or on other durable relationships, as the natural primary and fundamental unit group of society’, and would have eliminated another clause.


The second question concerned Article 41.2, which equality activists and women’s rights groups have opposed for decades. That article says that the state ‘recognizes that by her life within the home, woman gives to the state a support without which the common good cannot be achieved’ and that the state will ‘endeavor to ensure that mothers shall not be obliged by economic necessity to engage in labor to the neglect of their duties in the home’.


The public voted against replacing that language with a new article that recognized all family caregivers. The proposed article stated, ‘The state recognizes that the provision of care, by members of a family to one another by reason of the bonds that exist among them, gives to society a support without which the common good cannot be achieved, and shall strive to support such provision’.


Some opponents of the amendments had argued that the proposed language about ‘durable relationships’ was too broad. Others said that the care provisions did not go far enough toward compelling the state to protect caregivers regardless of their gender.


The retention of Article 41.2, especially the ‘life within the home’ clause, was met with disappointment from women’s rights groups that had long campaigned for its removal on the grounds that it was a relic of a patriarchal past.


The National Women’s Council of Ireland, a charity that promotes women’s rights and equality and had campaigned in favor of the proposals, issued a statement expressing ‘deep disappointment’ about the ‘No’ vote. The charity said that ‘while the reasons for this are complex, the result is a clear wake-up call that we cannot be complacent about equality and women’s rights’”. -Megan Specia, New York Times


The results of the Irish double referendum have demonstrated once again just how overtly unrepresentative of “the will of the people” supposed representative democracy can truly be while the national sentiment remains hostile to any progressive and postmodern reforms.

The Art of Protest

An anti-Israeli protest group named “Palestine Action” has vandalized and ruined a historic portrait on display in Trinity College, Cambridge, of Arthur Balfour, a UK politician and former Prime Minister whose 1917 declaration expressed Britain’s support for a Jewish homeland in then-Palestine to Baron Lionel Walter Rothschild.


“A pro-Palestine group has defaced and slashed a painting of Lord Arthur James Balfour, the British foreign secretary whose 1917 declaration was instrumental in justifying support for the establishment of the state of Israel.


A video released by Palestinian Action, showed an activist spraying the 1914 portrait of Balfour by Hungarian-born artist Philip Alexius de Laszlo that was hanging in Trinity College, Cambridge, and repeatedly cutting it with a sharp object.



Palestinian Action claimed that the Balfour Declaration marked the start of ‘ethnic cleansing in Palestine’.


The Balfour declaration promised to build ‘a national home for the Jewish people in Palestine, where the majority of the indigenous population were not Jewish’, the statement published on the group’s official website reads. ‘He gave away the Palestinians homeland – a land that wasn’t his to give away’.


The UK has seen frequent pro-Palestine and pro-Israel protests since October 7th last year, when the militant group Hamas attacked southern Israel, killing around 1,200 people and taking more than 200 hostages. Israel responded by declaring war on Hamas and launching a military operation in Gaza. Over 30,000 Palestinians have died in the conflict so far, according to Gaza health authorities.


Earlier this week, students from the University of Leeds occupied a campus building in protest at the university’s ties with Israel. The demonstrators demanded that university authorities dismiss the university rabbi, who returned to serve in the Israeli army after October 7th.


Last month, tens of thousands of people reportedly took part in a pro-Palestinian march in central London, calling for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza.


In January, a group of pro-Palestinian activists were arrested on suspicion of plotting to disrupt the work of the London stock exchange, and another group of protesters briefly blocked roads outside parliament. In November, Palestine supporters staged a sit-in at King’s Cross station in central London”. -RT


Defacing art is hardly a newly popularized form of political protest.


Ironically, the portrait of Arthur Balfour was painted by Hungarian-born artist Philip Alexius de Laszlo in 1914, the very same year that a Canadian suffragette and member of the Women's Social and Political Union, Mary Richardson, used a meat cleaver to hack six times into the prized oil painting by Diego Velázquez, The Rokeby Venus, at The National Gallery in London.



“As Richardson was bundled out of the Gallery, she proclaimed, 'Yes, I am a suffragette. You can get another picture, but you cannot get a life, as they are killing Mrs. Pankhurst'.


Though Richardson admitted that she didn't like the Velázquez, she was no philistine.


In a signed statement addressed to the Women's Social and Political Union after the action, Richardson declared: 'I have tried to destroy the picture of the most beautiful woman in mythological history as a protest against the Government for destroying Mrs. Pankhurst, who is the most beautiful character in modern history’”. -Victoria Ibbett, Suffragettes and Art Vandalism


Mary Richardson

Richardson, who went on to run the Women's Section of the British Union of Fascists under Oswald Mosely, committed the attack in protest against the incarceration of the founder of the Women's Social and Political Union, Emmeline Pankhurst, a suffragette who led the White Feather campaign to jail men who did not volunteer to fight in the Great War.


Emmeline Pankhurst

It’s fascinating to see that this young radical has mimicked the tactics of the English suffragettes’ campaign prior to World War I, considering how the Muslims whom she is militating in support of would, in all likelihood, sooner destroy any portraits or statues honoring Ms. Pankhurst and her egalitarian comrades then support her unfettered freedom of expression.

The Capacity to Consent

New York Senate Democrats have introduced Senate Bill S6103, which aims to permit any minor who is at least fourteen years of age to be immunized or put through certain surgical procedures without parental consent.


“Parents will be protesting a bill recently introduced in the New York legislature that that will allow any medical procedure or product to be given to any minor of any age without parental knowledge or consent. The demonstration will take place outside the office of Bronx Assemblymember Karines Reyes who introduced Assembly bill A6761.


The bill also allows children to automatically qualify for Medicaid to pay for any costs. State Senator Rachel May of Syracuse has introduced S8352, the identical bill in the State Senate.


‘The scope of this bill is difficult to  fathom, but it calls for completely excluding parents from any knowledge of what is being done medically to their children, much less have any say over what is being done’. Said Rita Palma, Executive Director of My Kids My Choice, ‘The bill allows drugs, hospitalization, even surgery, without a parent knowing about it’.


Parents are also asking why the official description of the bill misleadingly claims that it only pertains to ‘homeless minors’ and says it only allows ‘certain’ procedures, yet the bill would  apply to all minors in New York, and it covers all procedures, including drugs, hospitalization, and surgery yet appears on the State Senate website as, ‘Allows homeless youth to give effective consent to certain medical, dental, health, and hospital services; provides for insurance coverage of such health care services consented to by such youth’.



Nothing in the bill excludes children from being used in medical experiments.


If this bill is passed children of any age will be able to have healthy organs removed, but will not be able to consent to a session in a tanning salon or getting their ears pierced which are limited to adults by New York law”. -Michael Kane


While the bill’s critics have warned that, if passed, it would set a precedent for handing over parental rights to the state, one wonders if the legislators would be so eager to introduce the act if the complaint was that parents were forcing vaccines on their minor children and that the teenagers should have the legal right to refuse recommended treatments.

Political Pawns

The world's top chess federation has ruled that transgender women cannot compete in its official events for women until its officials make an assessment of gender change.


“The International Chess Federation, often referred to by its French acronym FIDE, has restricted transgender biological males from competing in women’s tournaments.



Last week, the organization said that they have been receiving increased applications from players who claim to be transgender and want to play against players of the sex they identify as.


‘Change of gender is a change that has a significant impact on a player’s status and future eligibility to tournaments, therefore it can only be made if there is a relevant proof of the change provided’, the FIDE said.


Decisions on each player would take up to two years to complete, the organization said.


‘In the event that the gender was changed from a male to a female the player has no right to participate in official FIDE events for women until further FIDE’s decision is made’, the announcement continued.


According to a report from RFI, ‘Holders of women’s titles who change their genders to male would see those titles abolished’, the federation said while holding out the possibility of a reinstatement ‘if the person changes the gender back to a woman’.


‘If a player has changed the gender from a man into a woman, all the previous titles remain eligible’, the federation said”. -Cassandra MacDonald, Gateway Pundit


It’s interesting how while transgender women cannot compete in events for women, a woman, or transgender male, would almost certainly be permitted and even encouraged to compete against men.


When one considers the implications of this recent ruling by the International Chess Confederation, it seems somewhat contradictory to, on the one hand, denounce the inclusion of trans women into female sports as being a threat to women’s athletics and, on the other hand, deny the fact the same discrepancies exist between the performances of men and women even in purely intellectual contests, such as the game of chess.

DeSantis Dumps on Trump

Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has continued to face criticism from within and beyond his party after his presidential campaign began touting his record of opposing pro-transgender legislation as part of a somewhat puzzling political attack on leading GOP candidate Donald Trump.


“Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, who's vying to be the Republican nominee for president in 2024, defended a video his campaign released


The video featured clips of then-candidate Trump in 2016 promising to support LGBT rights, allowing trans-identified men to compete against women in the Miss USA pageant and telling NBC's ‘Today’ show he would allow Caitlyn Jenner to use any bathroom he wanted at Trump Tower.


These clips were contrasted with headlines about DeSantis signing ‘the most extreme slate of anti-trans laws in modern history’ and a ‘draconian anti-trans bathroom bill’.


When Trump was president, however, his administration was criticized for rescinding former President Barack Obama's trans bathroom mandate on public schools.


DeSantis discussed the video with conservative commentator Tomi Lahren, who described it as ‘attacking Donald Trump for, I guess, his advocacy for the LGBTQ community’.


‘I think identifying Donald Trump as really being a pioneer in injecting gender ideology into the mainstream where he was having men complete against women in his beauty pageants, I think that's totally fair game because he's now campaigning saying the opposite — that he doesn't think that you should have men competing in women's things like athletics’, DeSantis said.


The 2024 presidential hopeful explained that he believes referring to gender as ‘fluid’ is an attack on women’s rights, and he condemned the practice of allowing men to compete in women’s sports as an attack on ‘truth itself’.


‘When they take a swimmer who swam on the men’s team for three years and then switches to the women’s team, and they say that’s the women’s swim National Champion, we know not only does that violate the opportunities for the other women swimmers, but we also know that that’s a lie. It’s not true’, DeSantis maintained.


The Florida governor asserted that there is value in making sure that society is ‘rooted’ in truth and not what he described as ‘social fads’”. -Samantha Kamman, Christian Post



One can’t help but notice how the origins of the transgender ideology are rooted in the very concepts consistent with Ron DeSantis’ civic nationalist ideals.


As a vocal proponent of “legal” immigration, DeSantis believes that foreigners who file for citizenship can transform their identity into red-blooded “Americans” so long as they receive sufficient legal documentation. While at the same time, the governor insists that a male with legal papers that recognize him as a female never truly becomes one.


“I’ve always opposed amnesty and stood up for the rule of law in our country. Cheap foreign labor is not an excuse to let lawlessness prevail in the sunshine state. We want people who come legally”. -Ron DeSantis


As it happens, some things cannot be defined on the basis of their legal status.


And, as even Governor DeSantis probably understands full well, naturalized citizenship does less in reality to alter the nature of a person’s national identity than sex reassignment surgery does to change the status of one’s perceived gender.

European Union Perverts Christ

An art exhibit at the European Union’s Parliament building in Brussels, Belgium, has prompted criticism from Christians for its display of a blasphemous depiction of Jesus Christ and the apostles.


“Conservative European politicians raged over artwork at the European Parliament in Brussels that depicted Jesus Christ delivering the Sermon on the Mount while surrounded by gay men dressed in leather outfits.


The image, which was part of a photography exhibition by lesbian Swedish artist Elisabeth Ohlson that ran in a restricted part of the EU Parliament building was an attempt to display Jesus as supportive of LGBTQ rights, the artist said.



‘There [are] a lot of pictures of Jesus with heterosexual [people]’, she said in a Twitter video in response to the backlash.


‘Millions, billions of paintings, famous artists. But this is just twelve pictures of Jesus loving the LGBT rights, so twelve pictures should not be so scary for them’.


The art was promoted by Swedish MEP Malin Björk, a member of the country's Left Party. The parliamentarian said during the inauguration of the exhibit that the art ‘shows that our societies have evolved in the past 25 years regarding LGBT rights’, according to Evangelical Focus. The art had previously been rejected for display at the EU Parliament in the early 2000s.


The art drew condemnation from some Italian, Spanish and Polish members of European Parliament, who described the work as blasphemous.


‘It represents Jesus surrounded by apostles dressed as sadomasochistic slaves’, said Italian MEP Maria Veronica Rossi, according to the Times of London.


Jorge Buxadé, a Spanish MEP, denounced the artwork as ‘disgusting and miserable’.


‘The European Parliament has become a space of impunity for the LGTBIQ+ lobby with the complicity of the left… and liberal’, Buxadé wrote in a tweet. ‘My infinite contempt for the author, the promoters and those who have allowed it’.


Deputy Prime Minister of Italy Matteo Salvini excoriated the art in a Facebook post. ‘Art? No, it's only vulgar and disrespectful’, he wrote in Italian. ‘In a word, disgusting’.


Ohlson has stoked outrage before, according to Catholic News Agency. She toured Sweden in 1998 with a series titled ‘Ecce Homo’, which displayed images of Jesus featuring themes promoting homosexuality and transgenderism.


When the series was exhibited at the Belgrade Pride festival in Serbia in 2012, it drew scorn from Serbian Orthodox Church Patriarch Irinej, who called on the Serbian government to ban the art he described as ‘deeply insulting’ and ‘blasphemous’”. -Jon Brown, Fox News


Freedom of expression was only ever an rhetorical weapon designed to replace the authority of the Church by transgressive intellectuals operating under the banner of the subversive Enlightenment.


Truth be told, the best way for Christians to defend Western civilization from depravity and sacrilege is to reimplement blasphemy laws and blue laws, seeing that enlightenment and egalitarian concepts are incompatible with Christendom.